I've caught Tier 2 fish, which should fulfill the requirements for this. Or does this perhaps not count for fish you catch offshore at your private island?
do you possibly have another fishing journal that is already partially filled? If so, the fame will be added to it instead of the empty one.
The post was edited 1 time, last by Amoebius76 ().
Yes, my bad! I had all three types in my inventory and they were being filled in order, not individually.