Good Point.@Retroman maybe you think again in especially the guild challenge, because imo there is a too high risk to abuse this mechanic.Atm with the guild challenge there is a way to get seasonpoints without interacting with other guilds, with the problem that it would be harder every time you reached a new level (lvl1 300 seasonpoints vs 100,000 keys; lvl 50 300 seasonpoints vs 5,000,000 keys) thats a good system i think. but look at it combined with your new system:ALL Season Points generated are now partially also shared with all alliance members. (this also includes Guild Challenge, etc.)
1. I level my guild (below called mainguild) to guildchallenge lvl 4 (1,200 seasonpoints with 1,000,000 keys)
2. now i make my own alliance with that guild (im solo in that alliance)
3. all players deposit their alts in that guild to get seasonrewards
4. with all mains, we create a new guild and join alliance.
5. i level new guild to level 1 in guildchallenge (75 seasonpoints to mainguild, 225 seasonpoints to new guild for 100,000 keys)
6. leave alliance with new guild, and
and now repeat step 4-6 in endless (there is no problem with 7 days alliancehopping penalty cause its always a new guild that is hopping and there is no minimum of time they have to stay). i can get 75 seasonpoints for my mainguild for every 100,000 keys we can get as guild!!!
if we get problems with 2 days guildhopping lock, we can create more guilds simultaneosly and join alliance just a minute before reaching first level up, so single guilds level slower but the result of points is the same.
In sum i can reach crystal rank with only 239,400,000 keys thats round about the same like now theoretically guild level 69 (which would be 20,700 instead of 180,000 seasonpoints if you do it fair like now)
and the funny thing in this way i can get crystalrank without enter one time a full loot PvP-zone (like it would be if i do crystalfights, castlefights, mage raiding, GvG, etc. the normal things to get seasonpoints)
so pls think again in sharing guildchallenge points with alliance because of the specific way the guild challenge scales
We will change it so the Season Points generated via the Guild Challenge are excluded from the Alliance Sharing.
Hm, I'm kinda for and against this. The issue then is guild that don't conquer territories will contribute no points to an alliance they are supporting while still being part of it, Which might lead to it's own problems. Maybe just make it that if a guild leaves an alliance those guild points from guild challenges are removed from the alliance? Does not need to go back to the original guild, could just be lost.
Kinda would need to be treated differently then points earned from other sources. The question I guess becomes how.